Get Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics PDF

By David E. Smith

ISBN-10: 1442615478

ISBN-13: 9781442615472

How do events with authentic competition prestige impact Canadian politics? around the Aisle is an leading edge exam of the idea and perform of competition in Canada, either in Parliament and in provincial legislatures. Extending from the pre-Confederation period to the current day, it makes a speciality of no matter if Canada has built a coherent culture of parliamentary opposition.

David E. Smith argues that Canada has actually didn't increase the sort of culture. He investigates a number of attainable purposes for this failure, together with the lengthy dominance of the Liberal get together, which arrested the culture of viewing the competition in its place executive; sessions of minority govt precipitated through the proliferation of events; the position of the scoop media, that have principally displaced Parliament as a discussion board for remark on executive coverage; and, eventually, the expanding approval for demands direct motion in politics.

Readers of around the Aisle will achieve a renewed knowing of reliable competition that is going past Stornoway and shadow cupboards, illuminating either the ancient evolution and up to date advancements of competition politics in Canada.

Show description

Read or Download Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics PDF

Best canada books

Get The Last Spike: The Great Railway, 1881-1885 PDF

Within the 4 years among 1881 and 1885, Canada was once solid into one state by means of the construction of the Canadian Pacific Railway. The final Spike reconstructs the extraordinary tale of ways a few 2,000 miles of metal crossed the continent in exactly 5 years — precisely part the time stipulated within the agreement.

Download e-book for kindle: Canada 1911: The Decisive Election that Shaped the Country by Patrice Dutil, David MacKenzie

100 years in the past, Canadians went to the polls to determine the destiny in their state in an election that raised concerns very important to Canada's nationwide independence and its position on the planet. Canadians confronted a transparent selection among loose exchange with the USA and constancy to the British Empire, and the selections they made in September 1911 contributed to shaping Canada's political and fiscal historical past for the remainder of the century.

Desperate Glory: The Story of WWI by John Wilson PDF

This e-book provides the tale and problems with the 1st global warfare in a transparent, concise and aim demeanour, followed on each web page by way of images, unique sketches or maps. Focussing on social in addition to political matters with a Canadian viewpoint, Wilson provides the problems of the conflict with intensity and compassion.

Download e-book for kindle: The Wars by Timothy Findley

Wiki quote: The Wars is a 1977 novel via Timothy Findley that tells the tale of a tender Canadian officer in global struggle I. Nineteen-year-old Robert Ross attempts to flee either his grief over his sister's demise and the social norms of oppressive Victorian upper-class society by means of enlisting within the nice battle.

Additional resources for Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics

Example text

That is to say, there was more than Tory cunning that thwarted them. The Conservatives brought to the new Parliament their pre-Confederation coalition of interests, now united behind the single Tory banner. The Liberals took some decades to learn and then master the formula for national electoral success. The preliminary test, to agree on a leader, proved inauspicious. George Brown had been expected to lead the Liberals in the House, but at a time when it was possible to hold a seat both in the Ontario (or Quebec) legislature and in the Commons, he was defeated provincially and federally in 1867.

The explanation for the successful channelling of this unrest lies in the leadership skills of Mackenzie King, the choice of the Liberals in 1919. Unlike that of Canadian party leaders before him, King’s authority derived not from the caucus but from a convention of members of the party outside Parliament. ’47 Indeed, King had been defeated as a candidate in the general elections of 1911 and 1917. ) the final step. Although the Liberal, King, blazed this political trail, others, including later Progressive Conservative leaders, such as Stanfield and Mulroney, followed it.

Here is further evidence that history is not so much unkind to opposition as that it pays opposition scant attention – an oversight that was not overcome after Confederation, when in place of an imperial officer and, later, revolving ministries there was now one man in charge who appeared for decades to have almost a monopoly on the office of prime minister. The events of 1849 in Montreal were not the finest moment for opposition in the Canadian system of responsible government. There is no shortage of reasons to explain the failure: the principle of responsible government was new; the political parties on whom the practice depended were raw; the British model was inimitable: between 1841 and 1858, for example, Conservative and Whig prime ministers, in the persons of Peel, Russell, and Palmerston, took turns on the government benches at Westminster; in Canada opposition had learned to act irresponsibly because it held ‘no hope of office and no means to call governments to account’;16 and, most of all, the imperative of dualism – composed of language, religion, and region – which had revealed itself a conundrum to opposition intent on acting as an alternative government.

Download PDF sample

Across The Aisle: Opposition in Canadian Politics by David E. Smith

by Kenneth

Rated 4.95 of 5 – based on 23 votes